﻿<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?><records><record><language>per</language><publisher> Islamic Azad University  - Saveh Branch (Islamic Teaching Department)</publisher><journalTitle>پژوهش‌های اعتقادی کلامی</journalTitle><issn>9899-1735</issn><eissn>9899-1735</eissn><publicationDate>2026-11</publicationDate><volume>16</volume><issue>4</issue><startPage>7</startPage><endPage>32</endPage><documentType>article</documentType><title language="eng">An ontological reinterpretation of “freedom” in Sheikh Mufid’s thought: Criticism of predestination and explanation of the theory of “gain.”</title><authors><author><name>Leila  Afsari</name><email>leila.afsari@iau.ac.ir</email><affiliationId>1</affiliationId></author></authors><affiliationsList><affiliationName affiliationId="1" /></affiliationsList><abstract language="eng">&lt;p&gt;The question of human free will and its relation to divine will has been a central debate in Islamic theology. The two extremes&amp;mdash;absolute compulsion and complete delegation&amp;mdash;were both rejected by the Imams of the Ahl al-Bayt (a.s.). Sheikh Mufid, founder of the Baghdad theological school, employed "kasab" (acquisition) to articulate a middle position. However, because this term became associated with the Ash'arite system&amp;mdash;where it denies human causal efficacy&amp;mdash;many scholars have misinterpreted Sheikh Mufid's view. This descriptive-analytical research, focusing on the ontological re-reading of voluntary action, asks: how does "acquisition" in Sheikh Mufid's thought differ from the Ash'arite version, and how can it affirm human free will? Through textual analysis of Awā'il al-Maqālāt and comparison with al-Ash'ari's perspective, the findings show that "acquisition" in Mufid's framework does not negate the agent's influence. Rather, it embodies a "theory of concurrent capacity" and accepts hierarchical causality. God creates the act and bestows power upon man; man, possessing this power simultaneously with the act, becomes its direct agent and acquirer, thus deserving praise or blame. This ontological explanation paved the way for the "position between the two positions" in the works of his students, Sayyid Murtaza and Sheikh Tusi.&lt;/p&gt;</abstract><fullTextUrl>http://kalam.saminatech.ir/Article/55529</fullTextUrl><keywords><keyword>Sheikh Mufid</keyword><keyword> choice</keyword><keyword> acquisition theory</keyword><keyword> ontology of action</keyword><keyword> determination and delegation</keyword><keyword> occasionalism.</keyword></keywords></record><record><language>per</language><publisher> Islamic Azad University  - Saveh Branch (Islamic Teaching Department)</publisher><journalTitle>پژوهش‌های اعتقادی کلامی</journalTitle><issn>9899-1735</issn><eissn>9899-1735</eissn><publicationDate>2026-11</publicationDate><volume>16</volume><issue>4</issue><startPage>33</startPage><endPage>54</endPage><documentType>article</documentType><title language="eng">The Challenge of Free Will and Artificial Intelligence: From Metaphysical Denial to Cyber Determinism and the Threat to Human Nobility</title><authors><author><name>Qasem  Tarkhan</name><email>Tarkhan@iict.ac.ir</email><affiliationId>1</affiliationId></author></authors><affiliationsList><affiliationName affiliationId="1" /></affiliationsList><abstract language="eng">&lt;p&gt;The issue of human free will is one of the most fundamental topics in philosophy, theology, and ethics, serving as the basis for human distinction and superiority over other beings. With the advent of artificial intelligence and the pursuit of strong (general) AI, novel challenges have emerged in this regard. This article, employing a descriptive-analytical method and a theological approach, investigates three levels of these challenges: first, the theoretical denial of human free will based on findings from cognitive sciences and AI predictive models; second, the practical restriction of free will in the form of "technological determinism" and its more advanced manifestation, "cyber determinism"; and third, the hypothetical challenge of AI itself possessing free will and its theological implications for "human nobility" (ashrafiyyat al-insān). The research findings indicate that AI predictive models never entail the negation of metaphysical free will; rather, they are merely based on behavioral patterns arising from nature and habit. Concepts such as "repentance" (tawbah) and "breaking the pattern" constitute the most important empirical counter-evidence for free will. Moreover, in the face of cyber determinism, the fundamental solution is not the rejection of technology but the strengthening of existential religiosity, moral virtues, and the Qur'anic concept of "Shakleh" (inner disposition) within the framework of "al-amr bayn al-amrayn" (the intermediate position between determinism and absolute delegation). Finally, even assuming the realization of genuine free will for AI, human nobility remains defensible by relying on the divine breath of the soul (nafkhah min rūḥī), the station of vicegerency (khilāfah), and the acceptance of the divine "trust" (amānah). The ultimate conclusion is that AI, at best, attains "functional free will" (not existential free will), and the question of its free will, more than a technical issue, serves as a mirror for recognizing the truth of the human being.&lt;/p&gt;</abstract><fullTextUrl>http://kalam.saminatech.ir/Article/55530</fullTextUrl><keywords><keyword>Free will</keyword><keyword> Artificial intelligence (AI)</keyword><keyword> Cyber determinism</keyword><keyword> Cognitive sciences</keyword><keyword> Human nobility (ashrafiyyat al-insān)</keyword><keyword> Al-amr bayn al-amrayn (the intermediate position)</keyword><keyword> Shakleh (inner disposition).</keyword></keywords></record><record><language>per</language><publisher> Islamic Azad University  - Saveh Branch (Islamic Teaching Department)</publisher><journalTitle>پژوهش‌های اعتقادی کلامی</journalTitle><issn>9899-1735</issn><eissn>9899-1735</eissn><publicationDate>2026-11</publicationDate><volume>16</volume><issue>4</issue><startPage>55</startPage><endPage>73</endPage><documentType>article</documentType><title language="eng">The Place of the Moral System in the Study of Mahdist Civilization</title><authors><author><name>Maryam  JavaherForoushzadeh</name><email>Javaherforooshzadeh@iau.ac.ir</email><affiliationId>1</affiliationId></author><author><name>Reza  Baghizadeh Pelani</name><email>baghizadeh@iau.ac.ir</email><affiliationId>2</affiliationId></author><author><name>Hojjatollah  Marzani</name><email>hojat.marzani@iau.ac.ir</email><affiliationId>3</affiliationId></author></authors><affiliationsList><affiliationName affiliationId="1" /><affiliationName affiliationId="2" /><affiliationName affiliationId="3" /></affiliationsList><abstract language="eng">&lt;p&gt;The present study aims to examine and elucidate the role of moral teachings within Mahdism in the formation of a new Islamic civilization. Mahdism, as one of the most fundamental doctrines in Shi'a Islam, is not merely an eschatological concept but serves as an active and civilization-building paradigm throughout history and in contemporary society. This research adopts a descriptive-analytical approach to explore the logical connection between the three core components: ethics, Mahdism, and Islamic civilization. Findings of the study indicate that the ethical teachings of Mahdism not only influence individual behavior but also play a pivotal role in cultivating a justice-oriented, spiritual, and responsible society. The culture of awaiting (intizar), in its authentic Islamic understanding, promotes personal development and social reform, ultimately leading to the realization of an ideal, civilization-building community. Among the key moral characteristics of true awaiters are honesty, justice, humility, patience, and self-sacrifice. Moreover, both Quranic and hadith-based teachings emphasize that the reappearance of Imam Mahdi (may God hasten his reappearance) is marked by the global establishment of divine ethics and justice. Therefore, the new Islamic civilization reaches its peak with the emergence of the Imam and the founding of a universal divine government. In conclusion, this study asserts that the development of morally upright and spiritually aware individuals is a prerequisite for preparing the grounds for the reappearance and the realization of Islamic civilization. This should be a central focus for educational, cultural, and religious institutions.&lt;/p&gt;</abstract><fullTextUrl>http://kalam.saminatech.ir/Article/55531</fullTextUrl><keywords><keyword>Mahdism</keyword><keyword> Ethics</keyword><keyword> New Islamic Civilization</keyword><keyword> Awaiting</keyword><keyword> Ideal Society</keyword><keyword> Global Justice.</keyword></keywords></record><record><language>per</language><publisher> Islamic Azad University  - Saveh Branch (Islamic Teaching Department)</publisher><journalTitle>پژوهش‌های اعتقادی کلامی</journalTitle><issn>9899-1735</issn><eissn>9899-1735</eissn><publicationDate>2026-11</publicationDate><volume>16</volume><issue>4</issue><startPage>75</startPage><endPage>89</endPage><documentType>article</documentType><title language="eng">Challenges and Opportunities in Teaching Critical Thinking: A Case Study of Sabzevar Education Department Staff</title><authors><author><name>Benyamin  Rah-Chamandi</name><email>royaovladi1370@iau.ac.ir</email><affiliationId>1</affiliationId></author><author><name>Moslem  Charabin</name><email>moslemch2015@iau.ac.ir</email><affiliationId>2</affiliationId></author><author><name>Mohammad  Karimi</name><email>Karimi.740@iau.ac.ir</email><affiliationId>3</affiliationId></author><author><name>Ali  Maghool</name><email>1060280205@iau.ac.ir</email><affiliationId>4</affiliationId></author></authors><affiliationsList><affiliationName affiliationId="1" /><affiliationName affiliationId="2" /><affiliationName affiliationId="3" /><affiliationName affiliationId="4" /></affiliationsList><abstract language="eng">&lt;p&gt;Critical thinking training, as one of the basic skills in modern educational systems, plays a vital role in developing students with the ability to analyze and reason. This article examines the challenges and opportunities in teaching critical thinking in Sabzevar city This research was conducted using a qualitative method using in-depth interviews with teachers and educational experts. Data were collected and analyzed to identify obstacles and opportunities in teaching critical thinking. The findings indicate that teachers are unaware of new teaching methods, pressures from traditional assessment systems and lack of educational resources. These are among the main obstacles in teaching critical thinking. Also, opportunities such as holding training courses for teachers, using new educational technologies, and creating appropriate platforms for discussion and exchange of ideas have been identified.&lt;/p&gt;</abstract><fullTextUrl>http://kalam.saminatech.ir/Article/55532</fullTextUrl><keywords><keyword>Critical thinking</keyword><keyword> quality of learning</keyword><keyword> modern teaching methods</keyword><keyword> modern educational technologies.</keyword></keywords></record><record><language>per</language><publisher> Islamic Azad University  - Saveh Branch (Islamic Teaching Department)</publisher><journalTitle>پژوهش‌های اعتقادی کلامی</journalTitle><issn>9899-1735</issn><eissn>9899-1735</eissn><publicationDate>2026-11</publicationDate><volume>16</volume><issue>4</issue><startPage>91</startPage><endPage>109</endPage><documentType>article</documentType><title language="eng">Assessing the Interpretive Accuracy of the Claude Language Model in Analyzing Challenging Verses of the Holy Quran; A Case Study: *Istiwā’* upon the Throne (Ṭā Hā: 5)</title><authors><author><name>Mahmoud  Rahmanian Koushkaki</name><email>2460021852@iau.ac.ir</email><affiliationId>1</affiliationId></author><author><name>Mohsen  Zarei Jiliani</name><email>2570116386@iau.ac.ir</email><affiliationId>2</affiliationId></author><author><name>Gholamreza  Sotoudeh</name><email>Gr_sotudeh@iau.ac.ir</email><affiliationId>3</affiliationId></author><author><name>Mohammad Amin  Pirbaniyeh</name><email>MA.pirbonyeh@iau.ac.ir</email><affiliationId>4</affiliationId></author></authors><affiliationsList><affiliationName affiliationId="1" /><affiliationName affiliationId="2">Department of Islamic Studies,kaz.C., Islamic Azad University, kazeroon, Iran</affiliationName><affiliationName affiliationId="3" /><affiliationName affiliationId="4">Department of Engineering, Kaz.C., Islamic Azad University, Kazerun, Irann</affiliationName></affiliationsList><abstract language="eng">&lt;p&gt;The present study evaluates the semantic performance of the Claude language model in analyzing the fifth verse of Surah Taha&amp;mdash;"al-Raḥmān &amp;lsquo;alā al-&amp;lsquo;arsh istawā" (The Most Merciful [who] established Himself above the Throne)&amp;mdash;as a classic example of *mutashābihāt* (ambiguous verses) and *ṣifāt-i khabariyyah* (attributive qualities known through revelation). Adopting an interdisciplinary approach at the intersection of Quranic studies, Islamic theology, and natural language processing, this article examines three main areas: This study examines the model's lexical and rhetorical precision in interpreting the metaphor of *Istiwā&amp;rsquo;* (Divine Sitting/Ascension), the alignment of its output with the exegetical approaches of major Islamic theological schools&amp;mdash;namely the Mu&amp;lsquo;tazila, Ash&amp;lsquo;ariyya, and Imāmiyya&amp;mdash;and the phenomenon of "theological illusion" in the processing of *Sifāt-i Khabariyya* (anthropomorphic attributes). The findings indicate that, while the model possesses a relative awareness of polysemy at the lexical level, it faces fundamental structural limitations in reconstructing the argumentative frameworks of theological schools and grasping the "suspended meaning" (*ma&amp;lsquo;nā-yi ta&amp;lsquo;līqī*) characteristic of the *Tafwīḍ* (delegation) position; these limitations stem from the inherent nature of statistical language processing rather than from specific technical flaws.&lt;/p&gt;</abstract><fullTextUrl>http://kalam.saminatech.ir/Article/55533</fullTextUrl><keywords><keyword>Istiwā’ ‘alā al-‘Arsh*</keyword><keyword> Large Language Models (LLMs)</keyword><keyword> theological illusion</keyword><keyword> Islamic theology (*Kalām*)..</keyword></keywords></record><record><language>per</language><publisher> Islamic Azad University  - Saveh Branch (Islamic Teaching Department)</publisher><journalTitle>پژوهش‌های اعتقادی کلامی</journalTitle><issn>9899-1735</issn><eissn>9899-1735</eissn><publicationDate>2026-11</publicationDate><volume>16</volume><issue>4</issue><startPage>111</startPage><endPage>130</endPage><documentType>article</documentType><title language="eng">A Jurisprudential and Legal Examination of Legitimate Freedoms in Iran: From Theoretical Foundations to Implementation Challenges</title><authors><author><name>Zahra  Jafari Sartang</name><email>kamrava1689@iau.ac.ir</email><affiliationId>1</affiliationId></author><author><name>Mahmoud  Qayyamzadeh</name><email>mahmoudghayoumzadeh@iau.ac.ir</email><affiliationId>2</affiliationId></author><author><name>Samira  Golkhandan</name><email>samiragolkhanadan@iau.ac.ir</email><affiliationId>3</affiliationId></author></authors><affiliationsList><affiliationName affiliationId="1" /><affiliationName affiliationId="2" /><affiliationName affiliationId="3" /></affiliationsList><abstract language="eng">&lt;p&gt;Legitimate freedoms,as one of the fundamental pillars of social justice, human dignity, and legal order, hold a foundational position in legal and jurisprudential systems. In the system of the Islamic Republic of Iran, these freedoms are rooted in two complementary frameworks: the principles of Islamic Sharia, particularly within Imami jurisprudence (Fiqh), and legal regulations including the Constitution and ordinary laws. Employing an analytical-descriptive approach and utilizing library resources and official documents, this article, while examining the historical background of freedoms from ancient Iran to the contemporary era, analyzes the theoretical, jurisprudential, and legal foundations of these rights. The findings indicate that the jurisprudential foundations of legitimate freedoms in Iran are based on principles such as the "Principle of Freedom" (Asl-e Horriyat), the "Principle of Permissibility" (Asl-e Ebaha), the "Principle of Justice," and the rule of "No Harm" (La Zarar), which, alongside Quranic verses and narrations (Hadiths), define the limits of these freedoms. From a legal perspective, Articles 19, 22, 24, 26, and 27 of the Constitution provide extensive capacities for guaranteeing individual, social, economic, and political freedoms, although all are conditioned upon adherence to Islamic standards, public order, and societal interests. Despite a relatively clear theoretical and legal framework, the of these freedoms faces significant challenges, the most important of which are: restrictive interpretations of religious and legal standards by competent authorities; the conflict between maintaining public security and safeguarding individual freedoms; traditionalist socio-cultural structures; and weak oversight by responsible institutions in protecting citizens' rights.&lt;/p&gt;</abstract><fullTextUrl>http://kalam.saminatech.ir/Article/55534</fullTextUrl><keywords><keyword>Legitimate Freedoms</keyword><keyword> Imami Jurisprudence (Fiqh)</keyword><keyword> Constitution</keyword><keyword> Public Order</keyword><keyword> Citizenship Rights.</keyword></keywords></record><record><language>per</language><publisher> Islamic Azad University  - Saveh Branch (Islamic Teaching Department)</publisher><journalTitle>پژوهش‌های اعتقادی کلامی</journalTitle><issn>9899-1735</issn><eissn>9899-1735</eissn><publicationDate>2026-11</publicationDate><volume>16</volume><issue>4</issue><startPage>131</startPage><endPage>156</endPage><documentType>article</documentType><title language="eng">The result of social monotheism in the theoretical formulation and process of realization of modern Islamic civilization Emphasizing the view of Ayatollah Martyr Khamenei</title><authors><author><name>mohamad arabsailehei</name><email>Arabsalehi@iict.ac.ir</email><affiliationId>1</affiliationId></author><author><name>Farideh  Pishvaie</name><email>f.pishvaee@dte.ir</email><affiliationId>2</affiliationId></author></authors><affiliationsList><affiliationName affiliationId="1">Associate Professor of Logic Department of Understanding Religion, Institute of Islamic Culture and Though</affiliationName><affiliationName affiliationId="2" /></affiliationsList><abstract language="eng">&lt;p&gt;The aim of the article is to discover the results of reading monotheism as a social doctrine in the formation and realization process of modern Islamic civilization with emphasis on the statements of Ayatollah Shahid Khamenei (RA). According to the commentators of Navandish and Imam Shahid's point of view, monotheism has determined the foundation of society and is the theory of society management. The result of this reading, that is, social unification, by influencing the material and spiritual fields, the field of insight and knowledge, and human agency, gives a new formulation of the theoretical issues of modern Islamic civilization and rearranges the process of realizing modern Islamic civilization. According to the findings of the research, which was done with documentary method and exploratory analytical approach, the result of social monotheism in the material and spiritual realm is the simultaneous growth based on the principle of expansive God-centeredness. In the field of vision, social monotheism and its accessories will redefine the collective and social and transgeographical semantic system around the axis of "Allah". This outcome in the field of knowledge will be the redefinition of concepts, problems and sources of knowledge. The result of social monotheism in the human sphere is the education of a monotheistic and dignified human being who does not behave purely instinctively and has monotheistic agency and activism in the path of civilization-building, and his horizon is civilization. In the process of civilization building, social monotheism is effective both on an individual scale, i.e., self-improvement, and on a social scale, and in the process of socialization, it promotes the Islamic society to a monotheistic civilized society and lays the groundwork for the emergence of modern Islamic civilization as a global model that brings justice, spirituality, and all-round progress to humanity.&lt;/p&gt;</abstract><fullTextUrl>http://kalam.saminatech.ir/Article/55535</fullTextUrl><keywords><keyword>Social monotheism</keyword><keyword> modern Islamic civilization</keyword><keyword> formulation</keyword><keyword> field of vision</keyword><keyword> epistemic field</keyword><keyword> process.</keyword></keywords></record><record><language>per</language><publisher> Islamic Azad University  - Saveh Branch (Islamic Teaching Department)</publisher><journalTitle>پژوهش‌های اعتقادی کلامی</journalTitle><issn>9899-1735</issn><eissn>9899-1735</eissn><publicationDate>2026-11</publicationDate><volume>16</volume><issue>4</issue><startPage>157</startPage><endPage>174</endPage><documentType>article</documentType><title language="eng">Sacred Translation as a Theological Act:A Doctrinal Analysis of the Concept of “Ḥanīf” in the Arabic Version of the Pauline Epistles</title><authors><author><name>Tahereh  Fahimi Najm</name><email>t.fahiminajm@iauctb.ac.ir</email><affiliationId>1</affiliationId></author><author><name>Abdolvahid vafai</name><email>a_vafaei@iau.ac.ir</email><affiliationId>2</affiliationId></author></authors><affiliationsList><affiliationName affiliationId="1" /><affiliationName affiliationId="2">Assistant Professor, Department of Islamic Theology, ST.C., Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran </affiliationName></affiliationsList><abstract language="eng">&lt;p&gt;The concept of ḥanīf is one of the fundamental notions in Islamic theology, closely associated with pure monotheism, Abrahamic faith, the rejection of polytheism, and authentic religious identity. The use of this term in certain Arabic Christian translations, particularly in the Arabic version of the Pauline Epistles preserved in Vat. Ar. 13, raises a theological question concerning the relationship between sacred translation, the target language, and the reformulation of doctrinal concepts. The central question of this study is whether the use of ḥanīf in this manuscript should be understood merely as a linguistic equivalent, or whether it may indicate the recontextualization of Pauline concepts within the horizon of Qurʾānic language and Islamic theology. Employing a theological&amp;ndash;comparative method, this article first examines the place of ḥanīf in the Qurʾān and Islamic theology, then explains the concepts of righteousness and salvation in Pauline theology, and finally analyzes the doctrinal implications of the use of ḥanīf in the Arabic version of the Pauline Epistles. The findings show that ḥanīf in Vat. Ar. 13 is not merely a linguistic datum, but rather a theological key term whose insertion into the Pauline text opens the possibility of a monotheism-centered reading of righteousness and salvation. Even if this lexical choice resulted from the translator&amp;rsquo;s communicative strategy, its theological function within the horizon of reception of an Arabic-speaking audience cannot be overlooked. Accordingly, sacred translation in an Islamic&amp;ndash;Christian context may become a theological act through which religious concepts are reread, recontextualized, and understood within a new conceptual horizon.&lt;/p&gt;</abstract><fullTextUrl>http://kalam.saminatech.ir/Article/55536</fullTextUrl><keywords><keyword>Comparative Theology</keyword><keyword> Sacred Translation</keyword><keyword> Ḥanīf</keyword><keyword> Islamic Theology</keyword><keyword> Pauline Epistles</keyword><keyword> Arabic Version.</keyword></keywords></record><record><language>per</language><publisher> Islamic Azad University  - Saveh Branch (Islamic Teaching Department)</publisher><journalTitle>پژوهش‌های اعتقادی کلامی</journalTitle><issn>9899-1735</issn><eissn>9899-1735</eissn><publicationDate>2026-11</publicationDate><volume>16</volume><issue>4</issue><startPage>175</startPage><endPage>194</endPage><documentType>article</documentType><title language="eng">Comparative Analysis of the Approximative Thoughts of Ayatollah Mohammad Hadi Marefat and Sheikh Tusi: From the Scientific Approach in the Fifth Century to the Civilizational Necessity in the Contemporary Era</title><authors><author><name>Mohammad ali Marefat</name><email>malimarefat1@gmail.com</email><affiliationId>1</affiliationId></author><author><name>mohamad marefat</name><email>m.marefat@iau.ac.ir</email><affiliationId>2</affiliationId></author><author><name>mohammad moeinifar9</name><email>moeinifar92@yahool.com</email><affiliationId>3</affiliationId></author></authors><affiliationsList><affiliationName affiliationId="1" /><affiliationName affiliationId="2">Azad university</affiliationName><affiliationName affiliationId="3">Assistant Professor, Department of Theological Sects, University of Religions and Denominations, Qom, Iran.</affiliationName></affiliationsList><abstract language="eng">&lt;p&gt;This article provides a comparative analysis of the rapprochement-oriented perspectives of Ayatollah Mohammad Hadi Marefat and Shaykh al-Tusi regarding the unity of Islamic sects. Employing a descriptive&amp;ndash;analytical and comparative qualitative approach, it seeks to identify and contrast the key components of rapprochement in the works of these two prominent Imami scholars. The study is based on library research and textual analysis of primary sources such as al-Tafsīr al-Atharī al-Jāmiʿ, al-Khilāf, al-Iqtiṣād fīmā yataʿallaq bi-l-iʿtiqād, along with related exegetical, juridical, hadith, biographical, and theological references, as well as specialized secondary studies. The research corpus includes the published writings of both figures and the views of contemporary exegetes, jurists, and theologians on their rapprochement-oriented thought. Data were examined through qualitative content analysis and comparative evaluation to highlight elements such as their approach to Sunnis, language of dialogue, method of critique, engagement with hadith and jurisprudential sources, and unity-centered Qur&amp;rsquo;anic interpretation. The findings demonstrate that Shaykh al-Tusi, in the sectarian climate of the fifth century AH, adopted a scholarly and non-confrontational stance toward Sunnis, avoiding takfīr, while Ayatollah Marefat, in the reformist context after the Islamic Revolution, considered rapprochement a civilizational necessity and sought to rebuild trust among Islamic sects by drawing on reliable Shiʿi and Sunni sources. Ultimately, the study concludes that Tusi was rapprochement-oriented in method, whereas Marefat was rapprochement-oriented in method, intention, and purpose; both played pivotal roles in shaping the discourse of Islamic unity.&lt;/p&gt;</abstract><fullTextUrl>http://kalam.saminatech.ir/Article/55537</fullTextUrl><keywords><keyword>Ayatollah Mohammad Hadi Marefat</keyword><keyword> Shaykh al-Tusi</keyword><keyword> Rapprochement (Taqrīb) Orientation</keyword><keyword> al-Tafsīr al-Atharī al-Jāmiʿ</keyword><keyword> al-Khilāf.</keyword></keywords></record><record><language>per</language><publisher> Islamic Azad University  - Saveh Branch (Islamic Teaching Department)</publisher><journalTitle>پژوهش‌های اعتقادی کلامی</journalTitle><issn>9899-1735</issn><eissn>9899-1735</eissn><publicationDate>2026-11</publicationDate><volume>16</volume><issue>4</issue><startPage>195</startPage><endPage>218</endPage><documentType>article</documentType><title language="eng">Proving the Existence of God Based on the Existence of a Relational Entity: The Perspectives of Jalal al-Din Dawani and Mulla Sadra</title><authors><author><name>seyed Amin mousavikho</name><email>mosavi3974@gmail.com</email><affiliationId>1</affiliationId></author><author><name>Einollah  Khademi</name><email>e_khademi@ymail.com</email><affiliationId>2</affiliationId></author><author><name>ABDALLAH SALAVATI</name><email>Salavati2010@gmail.com</email><affiliationId>3</affiliationId></author></authors><affiliationsList><affiliationName affiliationId="1">PhD student in Islamic Philosophy and Theology, Shahid Rajaee Teacher Training University</affiliationName><affiliationName affiliationId="2">دانشگاه تربیت دبیر شهید رجایی</affiliationName><affiliationName affiliationId="3" /></affiliationsList><abstract language="eng">&lt;p&gt;One of the significant applications of the concept of "relational being" (*wujūd-i rābiṭ*) within the realm of theology is its role in the premises used to prove the existence of the Necessary Being (*wājib*) and His Unity (*tawḥīd*). The primary objective of this research is to examine and analyze the Unity of the Necessary Being based on the concept of "relational being," as viewed by Jalāl al-Dīn Dawānī. Although there is evidence in Dawānī&amp;rsquo;s treatise, *al-Zawrā&amp;rsquo;*, suggesting the presence of both "relational being" (*wujūd-i rābiṭ*) and "being-as-a-relation" (*wujūd-i rābiṭī*), a broader examination of his sources and their commentaries&amp;mdash;specifically regarding the "positing of quiddity" (*jaʿl-i māhiyyat*) and the "non-cessation of the effect" (*ʿadam-i zawāl-i maʿlūl*)&amp;mdash;reveals that his perspective centers on the effect being a "relational entity" (*wujūd-i rābiṭī*). This theory, however, implies the independence of the effect from its cause. Such a separation between effect and cause introduces a duality into the realm of existence, the most significant consequence of which is the undermining of the proof for the Unity of the Necessary Being. Establishing the Unity and Attributes of the Necessary Being is a key outcome of Mullā Ṣadrā&amp;rsquo;s *Burhān al-Ṣiddīqīn* (the "Proof of the Truthful"). Yet, an analysis of Dawānī&amp;rsquo;s intellectual foundations reveals that neither his version of the *Burhān al-Ṣiddīqīn*&amp;mdash;which treats the concept of "existence" as a generic category (*maqsam*)&amp;mdash;nor his *Burhān-i Dhawq-i Ta&amp;rsquo;alluh* (an argument based on the exclusivity of existence to the Necessary Being and the "conventional/nominal" (*iʿtibārī*) nature of existence in contingent beings) succeeds in proving the Unity of the Necessary Being and its hierarchical levels. In other words, Dawānī&amp;rsquo;s belief in Divine Unity stands in contradiction to his broader philosophical framework&amp;mdash;specifically his adherence to the "primacy of quiddity" (*aṣālat-i māhiyyat*) and his reliance on "quidditative contingency" (*imkān-i māhawī*) as the middle term in his proof for the existence of the Necessary Being.&lt;/p&gt;</abstract><fullTextUrl>http://kalam.saminatech.ir/Article/55538</fullTextUrl><keywords><keyword>Proof of Divine Unity (Tawhid)</keyword><keyword> relational existence</keyword><keyword> unity of attributes</keyword><keyword> unity of acts</keyword><keyword> Jalal al-Din Dawani.</keyword></keywords></record><record><language>per</language><publisher> Islamic Azad University  - Saveh Branch (Islamic Teaching Department)</publisher><journalTitle>پژوهش‌های اعتقادی کلامی</journalTitle><issn>9899-1735</issn><eissn>9899-1735</eissn><publicationDate>2026-11</publicationDate><volume>16</volume><issue>4</issue><startPage>219</startPage><endPage>244</endPage><documentType>article</documentType><title language="eng">The Kantian Ghost in Formalist Theory:  A Genealogy of Greenberg's Impasse in the Dialectic of the "Sublime" and "Kitsch"</title><authors><author><name>Mahdi  Mehrabifard</name><email>m.mehrabifard@iau.ac.ir</email><affiliationId>1</affiliationId></author><author><name>Hossein  Ardalani</name><email>H.Ardalani@iau.ac.ir</email><affiliationId>2</affiliationId></author><author><name>Nafiseh  Namadianpour</name><email>N.namadianpour@edu.ir</email><affiliationId>3</affiliationId></author><author><name>Ali  Sadeghishahpar</name><email>sadeghishahpar@iau.ac.ir</email><affiliationId>4</affiliationId></author></authors><affiliationsList><affiliationName affiliationId="1" /><affiliationName affiliationId="2">Department of Philosophy of Art, Ha.C., Islamic Azad University, Hamedan, Iran</affiliationName><affiliationName affiliationId="3">Department of Art. Ram.C. Islamic Azad University. Ramsar. Iran</affiliationName><affiliationName affiliationId="4" /></affiliationsList><abstract language="eng">&lt;p&gt;The present research aims to genealogize the theoretical impasse in Clement Greenberg's formalism by analyzing the roots of this crisis in Immanuel Kant's aesthetics. Adopting a qualitative approach and critical genealogy method, this study, through a close rereading of the Critique of Judgment and Greenberg's key essays (especially "Avant-Garde and Kitsch"), engages in a comparative analysis of the concepts of the "Beautiful" and the "Sublime" in Abstract Expressionist works. Findings indicate that Greenberg's impasse was not a theoretical error, but a necessary consequence of the modernist paradigm of "originality." Greenberg attempted to defend an art (such as the works of Pollock, Newman, and Rothko)&amp;mdash;which was inherently an instance of the "Sublime"&amp;mdash;using the tool of "judgment of taste" (which is specific to the Beautiful). The originality of this research lies in tracing the "Kantian Ghost" and demonstrating how the attempt to tame the "Sublime" with the criteria of "Taste" trapped modernism in the "prison of purity." Consequently, Greenberg's emphasis on "flatness" as the last bastion of originality against Kitsch logically paved the way for the emergence of Minimalism and the end of the modernist narrative.&lt;/p&gt;</abstract><fullTextUrl>http://kalam.saminatech.ir/Article/55539</fullTextUrl><keywords><keyword>Clement Greenberg</keyword><keyword> Immanuel Kant</keyword><keyword> Formalism</keyword><keyword> The Sublime</keyword><keyword> Kitsch</keyword><keyword> Genealogy</keyword><keyword> Originality.</keyword></keywords></record><record><language>per</language><publisher> Islamic Azad University  - Saveh Branch (Islamic Teaching Department)</publisher><journalTitle>پژوهش‌های اعتقادی کلامی</journalTitle><issn>9899-1735</issn><eissn>9899-1735</eissn><publicationDate>2026-11</publicationDate><volume>16</volume><issue>4</issue><startPage>245</startPage><endPage>261</endPage><documentType>article</documentType><title language="eng">The nature and function of Zoroastrian deities in connection with fire in ancient IranAbstract</title><authors><author><name>Hadi  karamati</name><email>2949478451@iau.ac.ir</email><affiliationId>1</affiliationId></author><author><name>MirzaMohammad  Hasani</name><email>mirzamohamadhassani@iau.ac.ir</email><affiliationId>2</affiliationId></author><author><name>Sina foroozes</name><email>s.foroozesh@iau.ac.ir</email><affiliationId>3</affiliationId></author></authors><affiliationsList><affiliationName affiliationId="1">Department of History, SR.C., Islamic Azad University,Tehran,Iran</affiliationName><affiliationName affiliationId="2" /><affiliationName affiliationId="3">rtment of History, SR.C., Islamic Azad University. Tehran.Iran</affiliationName></affiliationsList><abstract language="eng">&lt;p&gt;Fire, It functions as an intermediary between the spiritual and material realms. Beyond its central role in religious rituals, this sacred element exerted significant influence on the intellectual, ethical, and even political structures of ancient Iran, acquiring diverse functions through its association with various deities.The present study aims elucidate the nature and functions deities associated with fire&amp;mdash;especially Atar, Mithra, Anahita, Rashnu, and Bahram&amp;mdash;within the framework of Zoroastrian theology and cosmology. It employs a descriptive-analytical method based on library research. The main research question is how and at what levels these deities are connected fire, and what function this relationship serves within cosmological and ritual structure of ancient Iran. The hypothesis posits that fire, as a mediating and multifunctional element, facilitates the interconnection and synergy of divine functions in the realization of concepts such as truth, judgment, purification, moral order, and victory.The findings indicate that the relationship between the deities and fire possesses a coherent and functional structure. Atar, as the direct embodiment of fire, safeguards divine radiance; Mithra, in the light of fire, fulfills the role of judgment and supervision over covenants; Anahita, in interaction with fire, completes the system of purification; Rashnu employs fire as an instrument for measuring justice; and Bahram utilizes fire as a force of victory and the triumph over chaos. Accordingly, fire emerges as a central conceptual axis within the religious system of ancient Iran, through which cosmic and social order is realized and the coherence of Zoroastrian theological structure is established..&lt;/p&gt;</abstract><fullTextUrl>http://kalam.saminatech.ir/Article/55540</fullTextUrl><keywords><keyword>Fire</keyword><keyword> Ancient Iran</keyword><keyword> Zoroastrianism</keyword><keyword> Deities</keyword><keyword> Atar</keyword><keyword> Mithra</keyword><keyword> Anahita.</keyword></keywords></record></records>